Follow us on social

Get to know blendnewyork




blendnewyork seo robot

Show some love!

DeStefano's Olde Erie

DeStefano’s Olde Erie

Destefano’s Olde Erie has the best food around and an atmosphere to match.

Try us and you’ll be convinced! Our recipes are authentic and time-tested. The ingredients are always fresh. The result? A menu that bursts with flavor.

Let’s talk service. Our dedicated staff at DeStefano’s Olde Erie are attentive and knowledgeable. Did we mention friendly? When you dine with us, you’re always in good hands.

Stop in the next time you’re in the neighborhood and enjoy an old favorite. Or, discover a new one. Either way, we’ll treat you to a dining experience that’s unparalleled.


  • Main Dining Room: Seating for up to 80 people.
  • Rear Dining Room: Seating for up to 40 people.
  • Vineyard Dining Room: Seating for up to 40 people.
  • Upstairs Bar and Dining Area: Seating for up to 60 people.

Catering: Contact us for all your on-site and off-site catering needs. We can custom design a menu to fit your needs.


  • Anniversary
  • Annual Dinners
  • Baby Showers
  • Bar and Bat Mitzvah
  • Birthdays
  • Bridal Showers
  • Business Meetings
  • Communion and Confirmation
  • Reception
  • Retirement
  • Weddings

7 West Main Street, Middletown, New York 10940

(845) 344-3743


  • Tuesday 11:30am-8pm
  • Wednesday 11:30am-8pm
  • Thursday 11:30am-8pm
  • Friday 11:30am-9pm
  • Saturday 2pm-9pm
  • Sunday & Monday – Restaurant Closed